What it is about
Hardly any organisation makes everything itself. Material, components, subcontracted work, transport, calibration, IT services or entire processes come from outside. Clause 8.4 requires these contributions to meet the requirements too, because the organisation remains responsible to the customer, no matter who did the work.
What is required are criteria for the selection, evaluation, monitoring of performance and re-evaluation of external providers, applied and recorded together with their results. How tightly control is exercised depends on how strongly a provider influences the result for the customer: the supplier of office supplies needs less attention than the heat treatment shop that treats safety-relevant parts.
Control also means that the provider knows what is expected: which products or services, which approvals, which qualification of personnel, which inspections, and whether the organisation or its customer intends to verify at the provider’s premises. What purchasing writes into the purchase order is therefore part of control and not mere administration.
Outsourced processes are a special case: part of the organisation’s own value creation goes entirely to a third party, for example coating, dispatch or customer service. It remains part of the organisation’s own management system and is controlled as defined in 8.1 and in the processes.
What the auditor checks
“On what criteria did you select this supplier?”
Whether there are defined criteria and whether they match the supplier’s importance. “We have always worked with them” is an honest answer, but not an evaluation.
“Show me the last evaluation of your most important supplier. What followed from it?”
Whether the evaluation has consequences: a meeting, an action, a conditional approval, in the worst case a change of supplier. A score that changes nothing is just statistics.
“Which of your suppliers are service providers?”
Whether the calibration laboratory, haulier, cleaning, temporary staffing, software and data centre appear in the review. Supplier lists often contain only the providers of material.
“Which processes have you outsourced, and how do you control them?”
Whether outsourced processes are recognised as such and whether control goes beyond a purchase order: agreements, inspections at goods receipt or at the provider’s, key figures, audits.
“What does your purchase order say about the requirements for this part?”
Whether drawing revision, material, inspections, certificates and, where necessary, the qualification of personnel are communicated to the supplier before delivery.
“How do complaints against the supplier feed into its evaluation?”
The link between goods receipt, complaint and re-evaluation. A supplier with several complaints a year and an unchanged top score shows that the evaluation is not alive.
Which evidence convinces
A list of external providers with their approval status
It shows who may supply, who only under conditions and who may not. Purchasing should know it and use it.
Defined criteria for selection, evaluation and re-evaluation
Quality, delivery performance, response to problems, certificates, price: which criteria count is up to the organisation. They must be written down and applied consistently.
Recorded evaluations with date, person and decision
The standard requires the results and any actions arising from them to be retained. The decision carries more weight than the score.
Purchase orders and agreements stating the requirements
Quality assurance agreements, technical delivery conditions or purchase order texts show that the supplier knew what was required.
Evidence of ongoing monitoring
Inspections at goods receipt, certificates, key figures on delivery performance and complaints, audits at the supplier. They show that performance is actually being observed.
Typical nonconformities
Evaluation without consequences
Suppliers are scored every year, but even a poor score leads to nothing: no meeting, no action, no change to the approval. The criteria then exist only on paper.
Service providers forgotten
The list knows the suppliers of material and parts, but not the calibration laboratory, the haulier or the IT service provider, although they influence the result. If this concerns individual providers, it is a minor nonconformity.
Outsourced process without control
An essential part of manufacturing has been contracted out but is neither recognised as an outsourced process nor controlled. If control of a process that directly determines product conformity is missing entirely, the system does not work at this point: a major nonconformity.
Re-evaluation overdue
The initial evaluation was years ago, the planned re-evaluation never took place, and the supplier is still regarded as approved.
Requirements not communicated
The purchase order states the item number and quantity, but neither the drawing revision nor the material nor the certificates required. The supplier then delivers what it thinks is right.
Buying outside the list
Because it had to be quick, someone buys from a provider that was never evaluated. This shows up in a sample of purchase orders.
Differences by standard
ISO 9001ISO 9001
In this structure, clause 8.4 belongs only to ISO 9001. The other two standards control external services elsewhere: ISO 14001 requires, in operational planning and control (8.1), outsourced processes to be controlled or influenced and environmental requirements to be communicated to external providers; ISO/IEC 27001 deals with supplier relationships, up to cloud services, in several controls of Annex A. If you keep a joint register for all three standards, you evaluate per standard against the appropriate criteria. In the 2026 edition, ISO 9001 speaks in 8.1 of externally provided processes, products and services instead of outsourced processes; the obligation to control them does not change.
How IMScollect covers it
In IMScollect you keep suppliers under external providers and suppliers, each entry with the service provided, the standards it applies to, the requirements placed on it, contact persons and whether it is an outsourced process. Evaluation is against criteria you define yourself. Every evaluation ends in a decision, approved, conditionally approved or not approved, and the person who decided. An evaluation with a decision can be neither edited nor deleted, so the evidence stays in place.
When creating a supplier you set the re-evaluation interval; a due date and a task follow from it, and the list shows which evaluations are due or overdue. On the supplier you see its complaints, its audits and the history of its evaluations. The AI advisor Conni suggests suppliers and evaluations; only what you approve is adopted.
Frequently asked questions
How often do suppliers have to be evaluated?▾
The standard sets no interval, but it does require criteria for re-evaluation. An annual cycle for important suppliers and a longer one for less important ones is common, plus an evaluation when there is a reason, for example after a complaint or a significant change at the supplier.
Is a supplier’s ISO 9001 certificate enough as an evaluation?▾
A certificate is a good criterion, but it does not replace evaluating actual performance. Whether a supplier delivers on time and without defects is not written on its certificate.
What is an outsourced process?▾
A process that belongs to the organisation’s own management system but is carried out by a third party, for example heat treatment at a subcontract hardening shop or dispatch by a logistics provider. Responsibility for the result stays with the organisation.
Do all suppliers have to be evaluated?▾
All external providers whose products, services or processes influence the result for the customer. For unimportant supplies such as office materials, control may be correspondingly light; the organisation should be able to justify where it draws the line.
