IMScollect
ISO 9001ISO 14001ISO 27001

Clause 9.2: Internal audit

Title in the standard: “Internal audit”

Do you check your management system yourself before someone else does? Clause 9.2 in ISO 9001, 14001 and 27001, seen from the side that examines your internal audit during the certification audit.

Philipp Kappe

Philipp Kappe

Founder of IMScollect

Updated 13 November 2026

What it is about

With the internal audit, an organisation checks itself: does it do what it set out to do, does it meet the standard, and does the whole thing work in everyday practice? This happens at planned intervals, not just shortly before the certification body visits.

There are two levels to this. The audit programme sets out, over a longer period, which areas are audited when and how thoroughly. It is based on how important a process is, what has changed and what earlier audits found. For each individual audit, the scope and criteria are then fixed, and the auditors are chosen so that nobody assesses their own work.

An audit does not end with the report. The results go to the responsible management, nonconformities are corrected and their causes removed, and the overall picture feeds into the management review. If you are certified or want to be, the internal audit above all shows one thing: that the system finds its own errors.

Whether this is meant seriously becomes clear within a few minutes of the certification audit, and it shows on the shop floor, not in the report: if someone can explain what has changed since a finding from the last internal audit, the internal audit is working. If everyone just points to the report, probably not.

What the auditor checks

  • “Show me your audit programme. Why is purchasing in it every year and maintenance only every three years?”

    Whether frequency and focus are justified: by importance, risks, changes and previous results. “Everything once a year” is a plan, but not a justification.

  • “Is everything covered within the cycle?”

    Whether every process, every site and every requirement of the standard is audited at least once over the term of the certificate, and for ISO 27001 also the selected controls from Annex A.

  • “Who audited quality assurance?”

    Independence. Anyone who is responsible for an area or wrote its processes themselves should not audit it. In small organisations this is a genuine question of allocation. A proven approach is for an external auditor to take on what nobody internally can audit independently, often just one day a year. That is sufficient if the split is recorded in the audit programme.

  • “What was the most important finding of the last internal audit, and what has come of it?”

    Whether findings have consequences: cause investigated, action implemented, effectiveness checked. And whether they reached the management review.

  • “How can I tell from the report what you looked at?”

    Concrete samples: order numbers, document revisions, interviewees. A tick next to “OK” does not prove that anything was checked.

Which evidence convinces

  • An audit programme with a justification for frequency and focus

    It shows that there was planning and that clauses are not simply being worked through one by one.

  • Audit plans and reports with scope, criteria and concrete samples

    They make it possible to trace what was actually checked and what a judgement is based on.

  • The appointment of the internal auditors and their suitability

    Training, experience and the allocation that shows nobody audits their own area. None of the three standards requires a particular certificate.

  • The follow-up of findings

    Actions with cause, responsible person and deadline, and the evaluation of whether they were effective.

  • Audit results in the management review

    This proves that management knows the results and has decided what follows from them.

Typical nonconformities

  1. The programme does not cover everything

    A process, a site or an entire group of requirements never appears in the cycle. With ISO 27001 these are often Annex A controls that are listed in the Statement of Applicability but have never been audited. If an entire site or an outsourced process was never audited within the cycle, that is a major nonconformity: the scope of the certificate is then not covered.

  2. Auditor checks their own work

    The quality manager audits the quality management system she built herself. Objectivity is then not maintained, even if the audit was thorough.

  3. Reports without evidence

    Checklists full of ticks, but no sample, no document revision, no interviewee. Whether anything was checked cannot be seen from them.

  4. Findings without consequences

    Nonconformities from the internal audit have been open for months without root cause analysis and without action, or they were closed without anyone checking effectiveness.

  5. The programme exists only on paper

    Planned audits were cancelled and never made up, or all of the year’s audits took place in the two weeks before the certification audit.

Differences by standard

ISO 9001ISO 9001

With ISO 9001 the process is the focus: from the order through design and development and purchasing to delivery, with an eye on customer requirements and on the operations clause 8. Auditing in a process oriented way means following a real case through every station rather than going through the standard clause by clause.

ISO 14001ISO 14001

With ISO 14001 the internal audit also checks whether significant environmental aspects are controlled, whether compliance obligations are known and met, and whether emergency preparedness works. The evaluation of compliance is a separate step in clause 9.1 and is not replaced by the internal audit.

ISO 27001ISO/IEC 27001

With ISO/IEC 27001 the selected Annex A controls and the Statement of Applicability belong in the audit scope. Some controls can only be checked technically, such as access rights or backups. Reports here often contain sensitive information themselves and should be handled accordingly.

How IMScollect covers it

In IMScollect you plan the audit programme as a three year overview, per department with frequency and responsible persons. Each audit is given a reason, scope, objectives and criteria, and you choose the audit points from the clause tree of each standard, with a short explanation of what the clause is about.

An audit covering several standards is divided into areas per standard, which you can assign to different auditors. The audit runs in fixed steps from planning through execution to the report. Each finding gets an identifier and passes into corrective actions, and the report is produced with versions and as Word and PDF. The AI advisor Conni helps with the audit programme, with questions for the interviews and with summarising the report.

Try it yourself, no call needed.Prefer a walkthrough? Book a guided demo →

Frequently asked questions

How often does an internal audit have to take place?▾

The standards require planned intervals, but no fixed frequency. A common approach is a programme that covers everything over the three year certification cycle and audits important or conspicuous areas more often. Before initial certification, the certification body usually expects internal audits and a management review to have taken place.

May an external consultant carry out the internal audit?▾

Yes. “Internal” means that the audit is carried out on behalf of the organisation, not that it has to be done by its own employees. What matters is that the consultant did not build the system they are now auditing.

Do internal auditors need a certificate?▾

No. ISO 9001, 14001 and 27001 require competence and objectivity, but no particular certificate. Evidence includes, for example, training in auditing, experience and knowledge of the standard. The guidance for this is ISO 19011.

Can one audit cover several standards together?▾

Yes. An integrated audit follows a real process and looks at it from several angles. The assessment remains separate for each standard: a properly approved supplier has not automatically also been checked for how it handles confidential data.

Further reading and viewing

Template for this clause

Philipp Kappe

Philipp Kappe

Founder of IMScollect

Philipp builds IMScollect. TÜV-certified auditor with a background in governance, risk and compliance, more than 200 audits conducted and supported.

This page explains in our own words and does not replace the text of the standard. You can obtain the standards from ISO(opens in a new window) or from your national standards body. Clause numbers and titles follow ISO 9001:2026, ISO 14001:2026 and ISO/IEC 27001:2022.