What it is about
In the management review, top management takes a step back and asks whether the management system still suits the organisation, whether it is adequate and whether it is effective. This happens at planned intervals, usually once a year, and it is the point at which the results of indicators, audits and nonconformities turn into decisions.
The standards set out which topics are on the table: the status of actions from the previous review, changes in the context and among interested parties, the performance of the system with objectives, indicators, nonconformities, audits and feedback, the adequacy of resources, risks and opportunities, and opportunities for improvement. Each standard adds its own topics, such as compliance obligations in ISO 14001 or the status of risk treatment in ISO/IEC 27001.
What matters is the outcome. At the end there are decisions: what will be improved, what changes in the system and which resources are made available. They are recorded with responsible persons and dates and reviewed as the first topic of the next review. The review is documented not as a formality, but because only then can you see later what was decided and why.
In the certification audit the minutes are usually read early, often during preparation. In a few pages they show how seriously top management takes the system: are there figures without an assessment, or decisions you can find again in the operation? The results from 9.1 and 9.2 come together here, and the decisions lead into continual improvement.
What the auditor checks
“What did top management decide in the last management review, and where can I see it?”
Whether decisions with responsible persons and dates are in the minutes and can be found again in the operation: as a project, as an approved budget, as a changed process. Minutes that only report are not yet a review.
“Who took part, and who carried out the review?”
Whether top management reviewed and decided itself, and not just the management representative on its behalf. Preparation can be delegated, the review and the decisions cannot.
“Have all the topics your standards require been covered?”
Whether every required input appears, for every standard you are certified to, and whether each topic has an assessment and not just a figure. Gaps show quickly when you put the minutes next to the list of inputs.
“What became of the decisions from last time?”
Whether the status of previous actions was assessed and open items were carried forward with a reason or closed. If the same decisions appear in the minutes year after year, the review evidently changes nothing.
“Is your management system suitable, adequate and effective?”
Whether top management has made a statement on these three questions, based on the inputs. An overall conclusion with no link to figures and findings is not very convincing; an honest limitation with an action against it is.
“When did the review take place, and why at that time?”
Whether the intervals are kept and the date allows the decisions to take effect before the next audit. A review in the week before the audit is not forbidden, but it often looks like a box-ticking exercise.
Which evidence convinces
The minutes with date, review period and participants
They are the central evidence for this clause. They must show that top management reviewed and decided.
For every required topic, the input with its source and assessment
Indicators, audit reports, nonconformities, customer feedback, supplier evaluation, status of objectives and, per standard, the additional topics. The source makes clear where a figure comes from, the assessment what top management makes of it.
Decisions with responsible persons and dates
On improvements, changes to the system and resources. Only with a name and a date can their status be checked in the next review.
The follow-up of decisions
The status of every decision until it is completed, and its assessment at the start of the next management review.
The overall conclusion on suitability, adequacy and effectiveness
A short, reasoned assessment by top management. It shows that the system was considered as a whole and not just topic by topic.
Typical nonconformities
Report without decisions
The minutes carefully summarise indicators and audits, but under “Outputs” there is nothing, or just “carry on as before”. No decision on improvements, changes or resources: the review has missed its purpose.
Required topics missing
The performance of external providers, the effectiveness of actions on risks and opportunities or, for ISO 14001, the compliance obligations do not appear in the minutes. If individual topics are missing, this is usually a minor nonconformity: the requirement is only partly met.
Top management was not involved
The management representative wrote the minutes alone and the managing director signed them without any review having taken place. In the conversation with top management this usually shows quickly, because they do not know the results.
Decisions without consequences
Actions from the review have no responsible person and no date, or they reappear unchanged in the next minutes, without status and without a reason.
No review in the cycle
No management review has taken place since the last audit, or there was none before initial certification. The requirement is then not met at all, and that is a major nonconformity: top management is not steering the system at this point, and the certificate is at risk.
Differences by standard
ISO 9001ISO 9001
ISO 9001 divides the management review into 9.3.1 to 9.3.3: general, inputs and outputs. The inputs here explicitly include customer satisfaction and feedback from relevant interested parties, process performance and the conformity of products and services, and the performance of external providers. The outputs concern opportunities for improvement, any need for changes to the quality management system and resource needs.
ISO 14001ISO 14001
ISO 14001 brings its own inputs: changes in compliance obligations, significant environmental aspects and risks, the fulfilment of compliance obligations, environmental performance and relevant communications from interested parties, including complaints. The outputs also include actions where environmental objectives have not been achieved, better integration of environmental management into other business processes and implications for the strategic direction. The 2026 edition divides the clause into 9.3.1 to 9.3.3, like the other two standards; a more structured management review is among the focal points ISO names for the new edition.
ISO 27001ISO/IEC 27001
ISO/IEC 27001:2022 is also divided into 9.3.1 to 9.3.3 and additionally requires changes in the needs and expectations of interested parties, feedback on information security performance, and the results of risk assessment and the status of the risk treatment plan. The outputs are decisions on improvements and on any changes needed to the ISMS. The minutes here often contain sensitive information, for example on open vulnerabilities, and should be classified accordingly.
How IMScollect covers it
In IMScollect a management review sets up the topics of clause 9.3 for your standards and collects, for each topic, what happened in the review period: audits, nonconformities, indicators, risks, customer feedback and the decisions of the previous review. The next review starts from this status.
In the meeting you assess each topic as adequate or as needing action, take decisions with person and deadline that become tasks, and draw a conclusion on suitability, adequacy and effectiveness. The minutes with charts are produced as a PDF, the participants who attended approve them, and further people acknowledge them. The AI advisor Conni summarises each topic and suggests a result; the decision stays with you.
Frequently asked questions
How often does a management review have to take place?▾
The standards require planned intervals, but no fixed frequency. Once a year is common; before initial certification the certification body usually expects a complete review. After major changes, such as a new site or an acquisition, an additional review can make sense.
Who has to take part in the management review?▾
Top management, that is whoever directs and controls the organisation at the highest level. The management representatives prepare it and usually attend, heads of department depending on the topic. Without top management the review does not fulfil its purpose.
Is one joint management review enough for ISO 9001, 14001 and 27001?▾
Yes. An integrated review is common and saves duplicated work. It must, however, contain the topics of every standard and record the outputs so that it is clear for each standard what was reviewed and decided.
Does the management review have to take place in a single meeting?▾
No, the standards do not prescribe a format. A meeting has proven itself, because top management reviews and decides together there. A review in several parts is also possible, for example in regular management meetings, as long as all topics have been assessed in the end and the outputs are recorded in a traceable way.
